Transnationalism and the Revival of Nationalism

By Andalusia Knoll Soloff and Trevor Getz
Is nationalism still relevant in the world today? Does it serve to unite or divide people? These are questions that are meaningful for many groups around the world.

Cookie Policy

Our website uses cookies to understand content and feature usage to drive site improvements over time. To learn more, review our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Photo of the Refugee Olympic Team during the Opening Ceremony of the 2016 Olympics. The refugees wave flags bearing the Olympic rings.

A world of nation-states

Since the eighteenth century, the rise of the nation-state has been a major force in world events. In our globalized world today, billions of people use the same social networks and listen to the same hit songs, wear the same style jeans, and play the same video games. Yet almost everybody is still a citizen of a nation-state, and national identity still motivates people. In fact, nationalism may be on the rise.

Sports offers an interesting forum for considering nationalism and the role of the nation-state. The biggest sporting events in the world—the Olympics and the Football (Soccer) World Cup—pit teams of the different nation- states against each other. They pursue medals while promoting national pride. Some scholars believe sporting competitions like these demonstrate the importance to people of identifying with a group. If group inclusion is an essential part of being human, then national identities and nationalism are powerful motivators.

However, sports also show the complexity of nation-states. For example, the United Nations recognizes 195 sovereign nation-states. The FIFA World Cup only allows those 195 to show their flags, even though 211 teams can participate in the qualifying games. Some of these flag-free teams represent communities that aren’t fully recognized nation-states. These communities include Kosovo (claimed by Serbia) and Taiwan (claimed by China).

Then there are the Olympic Games. Since 1992, the Olympic committee has permitted stateless people to compete in the games representing the Olympic flag. When Brazil hosted the games, in 2016, the first ever Refugee Olympic Team competed. Its ten athletes had fled war-torn countries including Syria and Democratic Republic of Congo.

Photo of a crowd of Portuguese national soccer team fans. Most of the fans are wearing red and green, the same colors as the nation’s flag.

Supporters of the Portuguese national football team displaying their national pride. By Raimond Spekking, CC BY-SA 4.0.

What does it really mean to have a nation-state? Why are some countries only partially recognized? What is the role of nationalism? These questions begin our investigation into the world’s nations today.

Transnationalism

After the extreme violence of the First World War (1914–1918) and Second World War (1939–1945), nationalism was regarded by many as the mentality that led to so much fighting and death. The world-renowned Jewish scientist Albert Einstein, who in 1922 fled Aryan nationalism and antisemitism in Germany, said, “Nationalism is an infantile thing. It is the measles of mankind.” After 1945, there was a growth in internationalism. It promoted the idea that the nation-states of the world must cooperate in order to prevent war and address the world’s most difficult problems. More recently, economic globalization has become a powerful factor in the way people and nations relate to each other. Products made in one country are sold in another, and the world’s economies have become increasingly interwoven. The development of international systems has made nationalism seem less important than it had been previously.

In recent years, some scholars of globalization have argued that we are in an era of “transnationalism.” Just as economics has become global, transnationalism is the idea that identity is now a global idea as well. The internet and social media connect people across countries and cultures and allows them to maintain personal identities independent of their national identities. Another important example of transnationalism is the diaspora: groups of people, usually migrants, who share a culture but live in different places, all far from their homeland.

The largest diaspora today, by nation-state of origin, is from India. Almost 16 million Indians live abroad, and that’s just counting recent migrants who still have Indian citizenship. They have relocated to many parts of the world. The largest groups live in the Arabian Peninsula (about 6 million across four countries), the United States (around 2 million) and Great Britain (almost a million). Millions more people of Indian descent have become citizens of these and other countries.

Photo of an Indian Diaspora event from 2014 in which a large group of Indian people are shown socializing at the London Foreign and Commonwealth Office. Large posters promoting business, innovation, and technology can be seen in the background.

An Indian Diaspora event at the Foreign & Commonwealth Office in London, 2014. By Foreign and Commonwealth Office, CC BY 2.0.

The resurgence of nationalism

Not everybody thinks nationalism is a bad thing, or even that it has been fading. For example, Gustavo de las Casas, a foreign relations scholar, believes that nationalism can unite members of a nation-state. It can motivate them to work together towards a common good.

Rwanda is one country where leaders are trying to use nationalism to help bring the country together. In 1994, a genocide was perpetrated there that left hundreds of thousands dead. The victims were mainly from the Tutsi people. Afterward, Rwanda’s new government promoted an idea called Ndi umunyarwanda, or “everyone is Rwandan.” It was an effort to promote reconciliation between two communities—Hutu and Tutsi—in hopes of preventing future violence. As part of this program, the government has forbidden people to speak about their ethnic identity. It also has promoted a set of values the government wants all Rwandans to share. The program uses newspapers and radio to promote inclusive nationalism in schools and communities.

The Ndi umunyarwanda program has its critics, however. Some argue that its emphasis on nationalism and obedience to the government is problematic. It discourages open discussion of the violent and difficult past. Others believe that the program favors Tutsi people over Hutu people, despite claiming to be inclusive. Certainly, it demonstrates how difficult it is for people to balance their different identities.

Nationalism based on race rather than state

As demonstrated in Rwanda, ethnic nationalism is another form that nationalist movements can take. It is based on shared race or ethnicity, rather than on belonging to the same nation-state.1 In the United States, the most prominent example is white nationalism.

On August 11th and 12th, 2017, the city of Charlottesville, Virginia, became a battleground between white supremacists and activists defending racial diversity. During the rally, known as “Unite the Right,” participants marched with Confederate flags. A symbol from the Civil War (1861–1865), this flag in recent decades has come to represent opposition to racial equality. The marchers also carried tiki torches. They were a reference to the torches that the Ku Klux Klan have used to terrorize African American communities. At the height of the protests, a white supremacist supporter drove through the counter protesters. He struck and killed civil rights activist Heather Heyer.

Ironically, modern white nationalism is deeply transnational.2 The movement was born on the internet and has connected white nationalists in various countries. Many of these groups share a resentment towards minorities, refugees, and immigrants. In Europe, most of these refugees fled Syria and war- torn African countries. In the United States, they are mostly migrants from Central America and Mexico.

Photo of white nationalists bearing Confederate and Nazi flags on a street in Charlottesville, Virginia.

White nationalists in Charlottesville, August 11, 2017. By Anthony Crider, CC BY 2.0.

Citizens of no nation

Nationalism often brings attention to people who live in a country but are not permitted to be citizens. Usually, these people are denied citizenship because they do not belong to the dominant ethnic group. Today there are more than 12 million people across the globe who are considered “stateless,” as they are not citizens of any country. How many is 12 million? Well, there are currently 78 countries that have fewer people than that as their total population, Greece and Austria among them.

Anyone born in the United States is automatically a citizen—it’s a system called birthright citizenship. The Fourth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution guarantees this right, but some opponents have argued that it should be eliminated. Birthright citizenship is the law in only 39 other countries. In Europe, and the majority of countries around the world, citizenship is only granted to newborns who have at least one parent who holds citizenship.

When a person is denied a citizenship, their access to basic rights is often limited. They may be denied access to public education, medical care, the right to open a bank account, have a job, buy a house, or even get married. They also are denied freedom of movement. Without citizenship, they cannot get a passport, and without a passport they cannot leave the country where they were born.

In Europe, one of the groups that has been denied citizenship and basic rights are the Romani or Roma people. Many of them fled the Balkans in the 1990s. They were forced out during a nationalist war in the region.3 Some lost their documentation during the war, while others never had citizenship. Due to racism and discrimination, their children are unable to gain citizenship in any European state.

Sometimes, groups within a country actually have only limited citizenship rights. One of the clearest examples of limited citizenship is the ongoing conflict in Israel and Palestine. Palestinians who live in the West Bank and Gaza Strip have Israeli passports. However, they are not afforded the same rights as Israeli citizens and instead live under military occupation. In 2018, Israel passed a new law. It declared the country the “nation-state for the Jewish people” in which “The exercise of the right to national self-determination in the State of Israel is unique to the Jewish People.” This leaves the Palestinian people, who have no state of their own, as outsiders in the country in which they live. Another group that thinks of itself as a people but has no state of its own is the Kurds. Thirty-five million Kurdish people live as minority populations divided among Iraq, Turkey, Iran, and Syria.

Further discussion

So what does the future hold? Are we in an increasingly transnational world where our identities as members of a nation-state are becoming less important? Or have citizenship and “root-for-my-team-only” nationalism become more important than ever? What kind of world would you like to live in? How these issues play out will have a direct effect on many the lives of everyone.


1 As you already know, “race” is not grounded in scientific evidence of shared background. Rather, it is a category that people largely invented based on just a few biological factors, especially skin color.
2 In fact, even the use of tiki torches—which come from Polynesia society—represent how much even these white supremacists rely on global ideas and technologies!
3 “Roma” describes the same ethnic group who were sometimes referred to by the racist pejorative “gypsies.”

Sources

“‘12 Million’ Stateless People Globally, Warns UNHCR Chief in Call to States for Decisive Action | UN News.” United Nations, United Nations, news.un.org/en/story/2018/11/1025561.

Keneally, Meghan. “What to know about the violent Charlottesville protests and anniversary rallies.” ABC News Network, 8 August 2018. abcnews.go.com/US/happen-charlottesville-protest-anniversary-weekend/story?id=57107500.

Casas, Gustavo de las. “Is Nationalism Good for You?” Foreign Policy, 8 Oct. 2009, foreignpolicy.com/2009/10/08/is-nationalism-good-for-you.

Collman, Ashley. “More than 30 Other Countries Recognize Birthright Citizenship - Here’s the Full List.” Business Insider, 30 Oct. 2018, www.businessinsider.com/countries-that-recognize-birthright-citizenship-jus-soli-2018-10.

“Countries in the World by Population (2020).” Worldometer, www.worldometers.info/world-population/population-by-country/.

FIFA. “FIFA”—Associations and Confederations.” https://www.fifa.com/en/member-associations

Kronk, Phil. “Dr. Phil Kronk: The Psychology of Nationalism.” Knoxville News Sentinel, Knoxville, 21 Nov. 2018, https://www.knoxnews.com/story/life/family/2018/11/16/dr-phil-kronk-psychology-nationalism/2023555002/

United Nations. “Team Refugees: Looking to the Future.” UNHCR, https://www.unhcr.org/news/stories/team-refugees-looking-future

Andalusia Knoll Soloff

Andalusia Knoll Soloff is a multimedia journalist based in Mexico City whose work has been published by Al Jazeera, Teen Vogue, Democracy Now!, VICE News, BBC, NBC, The Intercept, and Latino USA, among other outlets. Her reporting focuses on human resilience and dignity in the face of disappearances, state violence, land struggles and gender-based murders in Latin America. Andalusia is the author of the graphic novel Alive You Took Them, which is about the 43 missing Ayotzinapa students.

Trevor Getz

Trevor Getz is a professor of African and world history at San Francisco State University. He has been the author or editor of 11 books, including the award-winning graphic history Abina and the Important Men, and has coproduced several prize-winning documentaries. Trevor is also the author of A Primer for Teaching African History, which explores questions about how we should teach the history of Africa in high school and university classes.

Image credits

Creative Commons This work is licensed under CC BY 4.0 except for the following:

Cover image: Flag bearer Rose Lokonyen Nathike of the Refugee Olympic Team leads her team during the Opening Ceremony of the Rio 2016 Olympic Games at Maracana Stadium on August 5, 2016 in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. © Paul Gilham/Getty Images.

Supporters of the Portuguese national football team displaying their national pride. By Raimond Spekking, CC BY-SA 4.0. https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Fans_of_the_Portuguese_national_football_team_in_Cologne_1.jpg

An Indian Diaspora event at the Foreign & Commonwealth Office in London, 2014. By Foreign and Commonwealth Office, CC BY 2.0. https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Indian_Diaspora_event_(15555313281).jpg

White nationalists in Charlottesville, August 11, 2017. By Anthony Crider, CC BY 2.0. https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Charlottesville_%22Unite_the_Right%22_Rally_(35780274914).jpg


Newsela

Articles leveled by Newsela have been adjusted along several dimensions of text complexity including sentence structure, vocabulary and organization. The number followed by L indicates the Lexile measure of the article. For more information on Lexile measures and how they correspond to grade levels: www.lexile.com/educators/understanding-lexile-measures/

To learn more about Newsela, visit www.newsela.com/about.

The Lexile Framework for Reading

The Lexile® Framework for Reading evaluates reading ability and text complexity on the same developmental scale. Unlike other measurement systems, the Lexile Framework determines reading ability based on actual assessments, rather than generalized age or grade levels. Recognized as the standard for matching readers with texts, tens of millions of students worldwide receive a Lexile measure that helps them find targeted readings from the more than 100 million articles, books and websites that have been measured. Lexile measures connect learners of all ages with resources at the right level of challenge and monitors their progress toward state and national proficiency standards. More information about the Lexile® Framework can be found at www.Lexile.com.