Cookie Policy

Our website uses cookies to understand content and feature usage to drive site improvements over time. To learn more, review our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

OER Logo

Rethinking Civilization – Crash Course World History

Civilization is not a clear sign of human progress. The idea can support superiority, exclusion, and domination. Common markers like cities, writing, monuments, and states can also reflect inequality, slavery, control, and war. Many small-scale and nomadic societies can foster equality, freedom, health, and strong social bonds. In 1800 CE, less than seven percent of humans lived in cities, so the label leaves out many admired people and societies. We should judge societies by separate traits, not one broad package.

  • The video argues that civilization is a biased concept that can justify superiority, exclusion, and domination.
  • The video shows that common markers of civilization can reflect inequality, control, slavery, and war.
  • The video says many societies outside the civilization label also foster equality, freedom, health, and strong social bonds.
  • The video argues that civilization criteria are used in inconsistent ways and leave out many admired people and societies.
  • The video concludes that societies should be evaluated through separate traits rather than one broad civilization package.

John Green questions what “civilization” means and if it’s a good thing.

13:42
live
CC

Subtitles

×
HD

Quality

×

Key Ideas

As this video progresses, key ideas will be introduced to invoke discussion.

Think about the following questions as you watch the video


  1. What do the earliest civilizations have in common? What does food have to do with civilization?
  2. People often use the term “civilized” to mean having a refined culture. Does John Green agree with this definition? If not, what does he think is a more historically accurate way to understand the concept of civilization?
  3. What do states have to do with barbarians? As people who live in states, what three things do we tend to assume about states?
  4. According to John Green, what two things are really important for the power of the state? What’s needed to make sure those two things can happen?
  5. What is James Scott's “big idea” about people who live in the hills? What other evidence—from other authors—does John Green present which may corroborate Scott’s idea?
  6. What are some benefits to life in the hills? What are some drawbacks?
  7. Where is Zomia and how many people live there? What’s unique about this region?
  8. What makes it difficult for historians to understand people living outside of states?