The Concrete Problem
The Concrete ProblemBy Eman M. ElshaikhHow does concrete manufacturing release carbon into the atmosphere? Discover the role concrete plays in the climate crisis and what can be done to reduce emissions.Learn more at www.oerproject.com
2The Concrete ProblemBy Eman M. ElshaikhFor concrete problems, we need concrete solutionsDid your school or house collapse on you today? Did the road you traveled along crumble under your bike, feet, bus, train, or car? If not, you can thank concrete.Concrete is one of the most widely used substances on Earth—second only to water. Concrete is everywhere, and for good reason: it’s inexpensive, versatile, durable, and weatherproof. It can be made anywhere and is easy to shape. It doesn’t rust, rot, or catch fire. So what’s the problem with concrete? In a word: cement. Cement accounts for a whopping 8% of global emissions. To make concrete, you need to mix sand and gravel with cement, a gray powder that, when blended with water, binds the different materials together.The largest part of that gray powder is calcium oxide. To get calcium oxide you need to heat limestone, or calcium carbonate (CaCO3), in a giant kiln. If you paid attention in chemistry class you’ll know that removing the calcium oxide from this compound releases carbon dioxide as a chemical byproduct. That accounts for half of cement’s total carbon footprint. The rest comes from the fossil fuels used to fire up the kiln to red-hot temperatures, and from mining and transporting the materials.Adding lime to cement at a construction site. © Getty Images.Making cement generates carbon dioxide on about a one-to-one ratio; for every ton of cement we make, we release a ton of carbon dioxide. But we aren’t going to suddenly stop using one of the most common and useful materials on the planet anytime soon. In fact, the problem is largely caused by how much of it we already use: more than half a ton of cement per person per year. That’s three times as much as four decades ago, and the demand keeps rising. Over the next four decades, we can expect to use enough cement to build the equivalent of another New York City every month.
3The Concrete ProblemBy Eman M. ElshaikhThe enormity of this problem is daunting, but it also gives us many different places to look for solutions.Solution 1: Better materialsResearchers are developing lower-carbon cement options by swapping out parts of the cement or concrete for other materials. They’re exploring everything from different clays to volcanic ash to leftover materials from iron and steel production. Some of these lower the required temperature needed to burn the kiln, which saves energy, and others—since they replace the limestone—release much less CO2. This option can reduce carbon emissions by up to two-thirds. Cement plant and limestone mine in Thailand. © Getty Images.A major potential Innovation Pathway for cutting emissions is carbon capture technology. Some researchers are finding ways not just to capture the carbon from the environment but also to infuse it back into the cement, which makes the final product stronger and means less cement is needed overall. These innovations could reduce energy and emissions by up to a third. Still other researchers are exploring how to capture carbon from exhaust gas and make it into synthetic rocks that could then be used in the final concrete mix. Inspiration can also come from unexpected places, including microbes, seashells, and ancient Rome. Researchers are mimicking the way limestone and other sedimentary rocks are naturally formed. One company is using bacteria to create a limestone-like cement substitute without heat and pressure. This idea could reverse the process, using up carbon rather than releasing it.
4The Concrete ProblemBy Eman M. ElshaikhAnother innovation copies the structure of mother of pearl, which is both hard and flexible. The result is called bendable concrete, which could reduce carbon emissions by over a third if widely adopted. It’s stronger and more durable so you need less of it, and it lasts longer, reducing the total cement needed to build, maintain, and replace structures. And one more potential way to create more durable, sustainable concrete is to copy what the ancient Romans did: Use volcanic ash and seawater to make a substance that does not erode but gets stronger over time.Solution 2: Better energy and efficiencyOptimization is another important piece of the puzzle. While traditional cement production has unavoidable carbon emissions as a part of the chemical reaction, there are other steps of the manufacturing process that can designed more efficiently, or “optimized.” For example, electrification can help cement plants and vehicles for transporting materials utilize low-emissions sources instead of fossil fuels. Plants, kilns, and equipment can be upgraded to use energy more efficiently. Using waste incineration and biomass to fuel cement production reduces emissions and can also provide some ingredients for concrete. Innovations in this area really focus on the system as a whole and look for places to close the loop. Another effort to close the loop is research into the “sponge effect” of the calcium in cement. Cement creates a ton of carbon dioxide, but finished concrete actually has the potential to be a carbon sink, since it can capture and permanently bind CO2. Figuring out how to activate this potential is promising and can make recycling old concrete a far more effective solution.We also need to combat overengineering, which is what happens when we use more materials than we need. In many cases, less cement can accomplish the same job. We can also use precast building materials or reinforce concrete to use even less cement. On a broader scale, we should plan infrastructure to reduce car use. In addition to reducing carbon emissions from cars, this reduces the need for cement for roadways by one-third. The problem with the solutionsWe have solutions. So why aren’t we using them?Well, there are some logistical problems. For one, new materials, technologies, and techniques take time to be developed, scaled up, and commercialized. Some processes work only in factories and not on construction sites. or require materials whose availability varies by region. Some materials have limited availability or are not well studied. It takes time and money to do the research and train people in the use of these new materials and technologies. Codes and regulations are slow to catch up, so even when technologies are ready to use, they first need to be certified for use in buildings and infrastructure.Even when new materials are commercialized and certified for use, they’re not widely adopted. The green premium is a big part of the reason. Cement is an industry with narrow profit margins, so companies aren’t likely to voluntarily take on the higher costs of green cement, which range from 75% to 140% higher than for traditional cement.
5The Concrete ProblemBy Eman M. ElshaikhAction opportunities and careersMost consumers don’t interact with the cement industry directly. So their best pathway to help drive innovation in this industry is by supporting public policy. Policies can help in two ways, first because they lead to helpful regulations and incentives, and second because governments themselves are big customers of the industry.Governments on every level can create regulations and incentives. They can subsidize lower-carbon cement or require construction projects to use more of it. They can require construction projects to limit or recycle construction waste and optimize other steps of the manufacturing process. And they can introduce regulations to limit carbon emissions in cement production, which will spur innovation in lower-carbon cement. These regulations must work on many scales, and they must include agreements to distribute the burden of green premiums.Construction work on the Kansas Turnpike in 1956. © Getty Images.Governments can also have direct influence. They use a lot of concrete in public projects, so they have major buying power. They can influence the concrete industry by using green technologies in public projects. Then corporations that want to score lucrative government contracts will have to adapt and invest in research. There’s also a lot we don’t know. We need more accurate and consistent reporting about carbon emissions and the adoption of new materials, technologies, and processes. This is vital so we can assess whether our carbon targets are being met. We also need data about concrete itself, so we can reuse it more effectively. At every level, better data is needed to inform policy, research, design, and business.
6The Concrete ProblemBy Eman M. ElshaikhSo what can you do? First, survey the local situation. Who are the big cement producers and distributers? Do they offer any low-carbon cement options? Do your city or county building codes allow, discourage, prohibit, or incentivize green cement options? What happens to construction waste?Then you could make this information available to others in your community. Create factsheets and flyers to help local residents understand your city’s cement cycle—who makes it, how it’s used, and how it is or isn’t reused. Share these handouts with people in other communities so they can use them as templates for their own local awareness actions.For a problem on this big a scale, though, we also have think beyond the local. Infrastructure projects are ongoing, and in the United States major public works are on the horizon. Contact your lawmakers to demand that companies receiving government contracts use lower-carbon cement as well as efficient design and waste recycling. Coordinate a campaign to write letters to legislators who work on infrastructure projects and circulate petitions among their constituents.Cement will continue to pose a challenge, and we need long-term problem-solving. There are many career paths in which you can help solve the concrete problem. Engineers can innovate in civil and environmental, energy and processing, mechanical, industrial, electrical, and materials sciences. We need architects to design plants, buildings, bridges, and other infrastructure elements that uses new cement alternatives and less cement overall. We need ecologists, chemists, biologists, and geologists to research the minerals and organisms used in making cement and cement alternatives and to explore the potential of utilizing bioenergy and biomass in those processes.Finally, we need policymakers, economists, and social scientists to figure out how to market, incentivize, regulate, and distribute low-carbon cement. Urban and regional planners can update building codes, propose green design practices, and change the way we build cities. To interact with the cement industry, we also need business leaders. They need to understand the market, forge stronger connections between researchers and industry, and figure out how to commercialize and adopt the most promising innovations.
7The Concrete ProblemBy Eman M. ElshaikhEman M. ElshaikhEman M. Elshaikh is a writer, researcher, and teacher who has taught in the United States and in the Middle East and works to make climate change knowledge accessible to diverse audiences. She teaches writing at the University of Chicago and studies the history and anthropology of science, with a focus on planetary, space, and energy science.Image creditsCover image: Pillars of Creation. Neque porro quisquam est, qui dolorem ipsum quia dolor sit amet, consectetur, adipisci velit, sed quia non numquam. By NASA, public domain. https://www.nasa.gov/image-feature/the-pillars-of-creationAdding lime to cement at a construction site. © nicolamargaret / E+ / Getty Images.Cement plant and limestone mine in Thailand. © Suriyapong Thongsawang / Moment / Getty Images.Construction work on the Kansas Turnpike in 1956. © Bettmann / Getty Images.OER Project aims to empower teachers by offering free and fully supported history courses for middle- and high-school students. Your account is the key to accessing our standards-aligned courses that are designed with built-in supports like leveled readings, audio recordings of texts, video transcripts, and more. Offerings include a variety of materials, from full-year, standards-based courses to shorter course extensions, all of which build upon foundational historical thinking skills in preparation for AP, college, and beyond. To learn more about The OER Project, visit www.oerproject.com