Cookie Policy

Our website uses cookies to understand content and feature usage to drive site improvements over time. To learn more, review our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

OER Logo

Writing: Identifying Organization and Language/Style

Page 1 of 5
Checkmark Alert Banner
Did you know? You can access an editable version of this activity: Google Doc or Word Doc
WORLD HISTORY PROJECTORIGINS/ LESSON 4.3ACTIVITYWRITING: IDENTIFYING ORGANIZATION AND LANGUAGE/STYLEUnless otherwise noted, this work is licensed under CC BY 4.0. Credit: “Writing: Identifying Organization and Language,” OER Project, https://www.oerproject.com/1PurposeLook at the elements of organization and language and style to ensure you have a solid grasp on each of these essentials of good writing. By analyzinganother student essay to both identify and improve upon these aspects of the essay, you’llimproveyour own historical writing skills.Process1.Review the Organization and Language/Styleportionsof the OER Project Writing Rubric(you can find theseportionsof the rubric on page4). These are the elements you should look for when you review the sample essay.2.As you read the sample student essay on the next page,make sure you:•Circle the major claim in the paper.•Look for any issues with language and style,and underlinethe areas that could be improved.•Pick two of the issues you underlined,and write your suggested corrections in the marginsof the essay. Only one of these can be a spelling error.•Look for any issues with organization in the essay,and highlightareas that could be improved.•Pick two of the issues you highlighted,and write your suggested corrections in the marginsof the essay.
WORLD HISTORY PROJECTORIGINS/ LESSON 4.3ACTIVITYWRITING: IDENTIFYING ORGANIZATION AND LANGUAGE/STYLE2Essay prompt: Compare the similarities and differences between early Chinese philosophies about how a state should be ruled.Student sample essay:Throughout the history of early imperial China, various political philosophes arose in response to questions regarding the best way to maintain stability and order in society. Among the most popular were Daoism, Confusianism, Buddhism, and Legalism. Although each at one point played an important role in the governance of the early Chinese state, differences in political thought led to controversy among Chinese thinkers regarding how a state should best be ruled.Increased enforcement of laws and rules will be seen by citizens as a form of “prying and meddling,” leading to an increase in “infraction[s] of the law” (Document 1). Daoist philosopher Laozi argues that limited government intervention in public affairs will result in a more stable and peaceful state. The concepts of freedom and independence are important to the Daoist political philosophy, as is evidenced in Document 5. When asked if he would accept a government position in the kingdom of Chu, Master Zhuang scoffs at the state officials sent to retrieve him, telling them to leave. A government position would likely leave him trapped “dragging [his] tail through the mud” or stuck in an “ancestral temple... preserved as an object of worship,” unable to fully leave this world after his death (Document 5).Legalist thinker Li Si strongly disagrees with the philosophy of Laozi, arguing that a strict, authoritarian government is vital to ensuring that the public remain disciplined and that social order is maintained. He asserts that even the slightest of infractions should be met with “heavy punishment” so that the public is not tempted to violate state law out of fear of what “will be done against a [more] serious offense” (Document 3). The concept of civil obedience is important to Li Si’s Legalist political philosophy and he is firm in his opinion that the Chinese emperor should ban all texts detailing other political schools of thought. He maintains that “Those who dare to talk to each other about the classical texts should be executed and their bodies exposed in the marketplace” so that others will think twice before criticizing the government (Document 6).
WORLD HISTORY PROJECTORIGINS/ LESSON 4.3ACTIVITYWRITING: IDENTIFYING ORGANIZATION AND LANGUAGE/STYLE3Confusianism takes a much more moderate approach than the extremist political philosophes of Laozi and Li Si. Similar to the Legalist perspective, Confucianism argues that a strong government involved in state affairs is necessary to ruling a large population. However,unlike his Legalist counterparts, Confucius calls for a virtuous and fair government that engages in morally good actions. As is stated in Document 2, “He who exercises government by means of his virtue may be compared to the north polar star” (Document 2). Just as all other stars face and support the north star, a leader who rules with virtue will have the support of his citizens. For example, as the Confucian philosopher Mencius states, “If the ruler is humane everyone will be humane” ... [and] “if the ruler keeps to rightness, everyone will keep to rightness” (Document 7).Buddhist monk and philosopher Huiyuan does not fully agree or disagree with the Daoist, Legalist, or Confucian perspectives instead he acknowledges the existence of government in early imperial China but argues that Buddhist monks should be separate from it.Additionally, Huiyuan downplays the traditional divine and all-powerful image of a ruler, highlighting the inability of kings and princes to extend life or take away one’s sorrows. He further argues that because Buddhist monks work outside the framework ofan ordinary lay person’s life, they should not be considered of equal status to other Chinese citizens. For these reasons, Huiyuan believes that Buddhist monks should not be required to show the same acts of political worship (such as bowing before the emperor) as normal citizens.In conclusion, each political philosophy of early imperial China argues that a different form of government is best. These differences eventually became the basis of controversy among early Chinese philosophers regarding how a state should best be ruled.
WORLD HISTORY PROJECTORIGINS/ LESSON 4.3ACTIVITYWRITING: IDENTIFYING ORGANIZATION AND LANGUAGE/STYLE43.Score the essay on each row of the Organization and Language/Style rubricbelow,and circle the top two areasin both sectionson the rubric where you think the student could improve. ExemplaryProficientDevelopingNot PresentOrganizationPresent ideas in a structure that supports reader understanding of your claim and reasoning:Order the source evidence and explanations in a way that reinforces your argument.Explain how the evidence and reasoning connects and supports the claim.Craft a strong introduction and conclusion.Include clear transitions between each subtopic and section to show the connections among the ideas.Language and StyleSelect words intentionally to communicate ideas clearly, and:•Further your reader’s understanding of your claim and the argument you are making.•Convince your reader of the validity of your stance and claim.•Convey your knowledge about the topic.Usesentencestructurestypical inhistorical writing andvary them to:•Show connections among your ideas, claim, and evidence.•Convey your expertise.•Help the reader understand the claim and see the validity and follow your argument across your essay.Use formal writing structures and language.Use the conventions of the English language so that errors don’t interfere with the reader’s understanding.
WORLD HISTORY PROJECTORIGINS/ LESSON 4.3ACTIVITYWRITING: IDENTIFYING ORGANIZATION AND LANGUAGE/STYLE54.How would you coach this student on improving the organization and language and styleof their writing?