Cookie Policy

Our website uses cookies to understand content and feature usage to drive site improvements over time. To learn more, review our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

OER Logo

Investigation – Evolving Theories

Page 1 of 18
STUDENT MATERIALSSTUDENT MATERIALSS-1BIG HISTORY PROJECT / ASSESSMENTINVESTIGATION—EVOLVING THEORIESPurpose• Download the BHP Writing RubricPurposeThis Investigation encourages you to think about why theories change over time and consider how others have supported, extended, or challenged an original idea. Considering ways that new evidence and ideas have strengthened, altered, or challenged a view is an essential feature of collective learning. Additionally, this assessment helps you continue to develop your ability to make evidence-based claims to support an argument for document-based questions you will encounter on standardized exams. ProcessDay 1It’s time for another Investigation. This time, you’ll use Darwin’s theory of evolution through natural selection to think about how ideas change over time. This Investigation asks you to respond to the question, How and why do theories evolve?First, your teacher will ask you to write down your conjectures—best guesses—about when and how theories become accepted. Keep in mind that you will use the theory of evolution as a case study to explore how an idea evolves based on new ideas, information, and technology. You’ll have about 5 to 10 minutes to make notes and think about how and why theories change.With your class or in small groups, share your list of ideas. Next, your teacher will either hand out or have you download the Investigation 5 Document Library. As you review each document, you’ll use the graphic organizer to record the major claims from each source and to document the evidence that supports those claims. Day 2Now it’s time to write! You’ll develop a five- to six-paragraph essay arguing how and why a theory evolves, using evidence from the case study of Darwin’s theory of evolution. Remember to use information from the Investigation 5 Document Library along with BHP concepts and other information you’ve learned in this unit as evidence to support your argument or opposing point of view. It is also important that you cite the sources you use as evidence in your essay.
STUDENT MATERIALSSTUDENT MATERIALSS-2BIG HISTORY PROJECT / ASSESSMENTINVESTIGATION—EVOLVING THEORIESINVESTIGATION 5Directions: Write a five- to six-paragraph essay in response to the question below. Make sure to use the documents provided to help support your argument or to acknowledge the opposing point of view. Remember to review the criteria on the BHP Writing Rubric. How and why do theories evolve?
STUDENT MATERIALSSTUDENT MATERIALSS-3BIG HISTORY PROJECT / ASSESSMENTINVESTIGATION—EVOLVING THEORIESRESEARCHING THE INVESTIGATION LIBRARY WORKSHEETDirections: Fill out this worksheet for each text in the Investigation Library. Author and title of textType of document (for example, article, letter, chart, map)DatePrimarySecondaryWhat do you know about this author/source?Do you trust this author/source? Why? Why not?What was the original purpose of this document?What’s the main idea of this document?How does this document help you answer the Investigation question?What other document or concept supports or challenges the information in this document?
STUDENT MATERIALSSTUDENT MATERIALSS-4BIG HISTORY PROJECT / ASSESSMENTINVESTIGATION—EVOLVING THEORIESInvestigation 5 LibraryText 1: Evidence For and Problems with Darwin’s Theory ........................................................................................................................5Text 2: Charles Lyell, Principles of Geology ..............................................................................................................................................6Text 3: Darwinism Fifty Years After: The Biological Lesson of Evolution .................................................................................................7Text 4: The 1933 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine Awarded To Thomas H. Morgan .......................................................................7Text 5: Genetics .........................................................................................................................................................................................9Text 6: BHP Chart on the Age of the Earth 2017 .......................................................................................................................................10Text 7: Crick’s Letter to His Son ................................................................................................................................................................11Text 8 The Episodic Nature of Evolutionary Change .................................................................................................................................15Text 9: Drug Resistance Explained ............................................................................................................................................................16
STUDENT MATERIALSSTUDENT MATERIALSS-5BIG HISTORY PROJECT / ASSESSMENTINVESTIGATION—EVOLVING THEORIESText 1: Evidence for and Problems with Darwin’s Theory“Darwin’s theory of natural selection rested on three kinds of evidence: (1) fossils, which showed that species have changed; (2) geographic distribution, like the data he collected on the Galapagos Islands, which showed that species are descended from local ancestors, not products of deliberate engineering by a creator; and on (3) homologies, or unexpected similarities between species. In addition to religious objections, real gaps in the knowledge of his day hindered Darwin as he defended his theory. His problems were that (l) he believed natural selection moved too slowly ever to be observed in one lifetime, (2) he did not understand how characteristics are inherited, (3) he could not prove that species were related, and (4) he did not know how old Earth is. In the first edition of The Origin of Species Darwin estimated the age of the Earth at some 300 million years, while his learned contemporaries were calculating much less than that.Darwin did not know how heredity, or inheritance, worked; no one in his day understood the specific way in which traits are passed from parents to their offspring. Darwin adopted a theory called pangenesis. This theory implied that parental traits are combined, rather than being transmitted as separate units, which would dilute the potentially successful mutations of one individual and undermine the whole theory of natural selection. Gregor Mendel (1822–84), an Austrian Augustinian monk, demonstrated in his studies of peas, published only two years after The Origin of Species, that for many traits the offspring show either the characteristics of mother or father, not a blend of the two. Mendel’s work, however, received little attention for many years, when it eventually became clear that it was the basis for a whole new theory of heredity.”Source: BHP created this text from Christian, David, Cynthia Stokes Brown, and Craig Benjamin. Big History: Between Nothing and Everything (New York: McGraw Hill Education, 2014) 60- 62.Who are the authors? You should be familiar with the authors of Big History: Between Nothing and Everything, David Christian, Cynthia Stokes Brown, and Craig Benjamin. Not only are they leaders in the big history field but they also created some of the content for the Big History Project curriculum. As you might know, David Christian created a course covering almost 14 billion years in 1989 in Sydney, Australia and named it “big history.” After learning of Christian’s work, Cynthia Stokes Brown began to offer such a course at the Dominican University of California. Craig Benjamin was a student of David Christian’s in Australia, where he assisted Christian in teaching big history. Dr. Benjamin is now a professor at Grand Valley State University in Michigan, U.S.A.
STUDENT MATERIALSSTUDENT MATERIALSS-6BIG HISTORY PROJECT / ASSESSMENTINVESTIGATION—EVOLVING THEORIESText 2: Charles Lyell, Principles of GeologyWho is the author? Charles Lyell (1797–1875) was a British lawyer and the foremost geologist of his day. He is the author of Principles of Geology: An Attempt to Explain the Former Changes of the Earth’s Surface by Reference to Causes Now in Operation. The book argues that slow-moving forces still in operation today, such as erosion, have been shaping the Earth for about 300 million years—the approximate age of the Earth according to Lyell. Lyell’s Principles of Geology was one of the few books that Darwin carried on his famous voyage on the HMS Beagle.“Geology is the science which investigates the successive changes that have taken place in the organic and inorganic kingdoms of nature. It inquires into the causes of these changes. And it describes the influence which they have exerted in modifying the surface and external structure of our planet.The form of a coast, the layout of the interior of a country, the existence and extent of lakes, valleys, and mountains, can often be traced to earthquakes and volcanoes in regions which are now tranquil. These ancient upheavals are the reason why some lands are fertile, and others are sterile. They determine the elevation of land above the sea, the climate, and various peculiarities. Much of the Earth’s surface was formed by slow operations such as the gradual depositing of sediment in a lake or in the ocean. To select another example, we find in certain areas underground deposits of coal, consisting of vegetable matter which drifted into what were formerly seas and lakes. These seas and lakes have since been filled up. The lands the forests once grew upon have disappeared or changed their form, the rivers and currents which floated the vegetable masses can no longer be traced. And the plants belonged to species which have passed away from the surface of our planet ages ago.”Source: Charles Lyell, Principles of Geology (London: John Murray, 1830), excerpts taken from Chapter I.
STUDENT MATERIALSSTUDENT MATERIALSS-7BIG HISTORY PROJECT / ASSESSMENTINVESTIGATION—EVOLVING THEORIESText 3: Darwinism Fifty Years After: The Biological Lesson of EvolutionBy David Starr JordanPresident of Leland Stanford, Jr. University.“It is a century since the birth of Darwin and half a century since the publication of the “Origin of Species,” the great book of the nineteenth century, and one which changed the entire face of biology and of philosophy.Darwin showed that competition is at work everywhere and favors the individual who can best make headway as young or as adult in the conditions that actually are. The struggle for existence is ever present. The essential factors in “organic evolution” are (1) variation, which Darwin took as a fact without explanation; (2) heredity, which he also took as a fact, with an attempt at explanation, as nearly adequate as the scanty knowledge of histology [the microscopic study of cells of plants and animals] in his day would permit; and (3) selection.Now, after these fifty years what is our conception of organic evolution?Since Darwin’s time, the compound microscope has opened the secrets of histology [the microscopic study of cells of plants and animals]. We have given meaning to the “physical basis of heredity.” We have learned the process by which two germ cells from two different individuals divide and mingle to form a new individual. With the microscope, we have traced the life history of thousands of species, from germ cell to adult life.The discovery of Gregor Mendel’s ideas has proved a valuable basis for investigation in the methods of heredity. But no change in the theory of Darwinism is made necessary by it. The position of Darwin is very safe standing ground.The chief and essential contention of Darwin, that species are formed by natural tangible processes, is now absolutely beyond question from those competent to form an opinion. That the animals and plants today, man included, are descended from the animals and plants of earlier periods by natural lines of descent with natural modifications, due to innate and external causes, is one of the certainties of science.”Source: BHP created this text from Jordan, David Starr. “Darwinism Fifty Years After.” Scientific American Supplement, February 21, 2009: 134–35.Who was David Starr Jordan? (1851–1931) was a naturalist, an educator, and a very important ichthyologist. Ichthyology is the scientific study of fish. During his career, Jordan named more than 2,500 species of fish. He taught biology at Butler University, Indiana University, and Stanford University. In 1891, he became the first president of Leland Stanford Junior University, now Stanford University. He was an early contributor to the theory of Darwinian evolution and was one of the major promoters of the eugenics movement in the United States. An interesting, though unrelated, fact is Dr. Jordan enjoyed the company of his pet monkeys at his home. The David Starr Jordan Prize is awarded every 3 years for “innovative contributions to the study of evolution, ecology, population or organismal biology.” More information about Dr. Jordan can be found at https://goo.gl/ENw0AU
STUDENT MATERIALSSTUDENT MATERIALSS-8BIG HISTORY PROJECT / ASSESSMENTINVESTIGATION—EVOLVING THEORIESText 4: The 1933 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine Awarded to Thomas H. MorganWhat are the Nobel Prizes? The Nobel Prizes are awards given to those who have had done their best to benefit mankind in the fields of physics, chemistry, medicine, literature, and peace. Created by Alfred Nobel, an inventor and businessman, the first awards were given in 1901. The winners get a diploma, a medal, and a cash award that has ranged between $350,000 and $1.5 million. All Nobel Prizes are awarded in Stockholm, Sweden, except for the Nobel Peace Prize, which is awarded in Oslo, Norway Who was Thomas Hunt Morgan? By conducting statistical studies of the way genetic traits are passed on in fruit flies, Thomas Hunt Morgan broke new ground in genetics during the first decade of the 20th century. Morgan used fruit flies to study inheritance to show that genes are stored in chromosomes inside cell nuclei... He was one of the first to move Mendel’s genetics from the plant world to the animal world by studying fruit flies? Why fruit flies? First, the fruit fly can create a large number of children in two weeks and 30 generations in just one year. So, Morgan would not have to wait for a year or more to see a change in heredity. Second, the fruit fly has only four chromosomes and so it was easier to show how a gene located on one of those chromosomes could pass on a trait from one generation to another. In this way, Morgan and his students were easily able to see the results of mating individual flies having specific characteristics. For his discoveries about the role of the chromosome in heredity he won the 1933 Nobel Prize.Excerpts from speech awarding Thomas Hunt Morgan the Nobel Prize in 1933 “Modern hereditary researches are of a recent date.... Their founder is the Augustine monk Gregor Mendel...who published (1866) his experiments on hybridization among plants.... Mendel’s observations are of revolutionizing importance. As a matter of fact they completely upset the older theories of heredity, although this was not at all appreciated by his contemporaries. Mendel’s discoveries met with the same fate as many other great discoveries that have been made before their time. Their significance was not understood. They fell into oblivion. Darwin apparently knew nothing about his great contemporary.... [O]therwise he could have made use of Mendel’s works for his own researches... [T]he rediscovery of Mendel’s work was made only about 1900. When, at last, Mendel’s discoveries came to light, their significance was soon perceived. In 1910, the American zoologist Thomas Hunt Morgan began his researches in heredity. These soon led him to the great discoveries regarding the functions of the chromosomes as the bearers of heredity that have now been rewarded with the Nobel Prize for Medicine in 1933. The results of the Morgan school are daring, even fantastic[.] [T]hey are of a greatness that puts most other biological discoveries into the shade. Human hereditary researches have already made great use of Morgan’s investigations. Without them modern human genetics and also human eugenics would be impractical.”Source: BHP created this text from the speech made on the Nobel Ceremony honoring Dr. Morgan, December 10, 1933 (entire speech at https://goo.gl/yFz6qk)
STUDENT MATERIALSSTUDENT MATERIALSS-9BIG HISTORY PROJECT / ASSESSMENTINVESTIGATION—EVOLVING THEORIESText 5: GeneticsThe organized study of the mechanism of heredity and evolution began only with the 20th century and the rediscovery of the lost work of Gregor Mendel.“Man’s deepest urge...is to understand himself and his place in the Universe, to fathom his own nature as a living organism.In this quest for self-understanding no investigation of the past 50 years has been more enlightening...than the study of heredity. The discovery of the basic laws of heredity is one of the major conquests of 20th-century science. Genetics has become a cornerstone of modern biology.Genetics is peculiarly a science of our century. To be sure, its founder, the Austrian monk Gregor Mendel, reported his historic conclusions from his experiments with peas in 1865. But, nobody then paid attention to them. It was in the year 1900 that Hugo de Vries rediscovered Mendel’s findings and thereby initiated the growth of a new science. By then biology was prepared to appreciate the significance of Mendel’s work, and from 1900 on the study of heredity developed very rapid.Very early in the study of genetics biologists began to pay particular attention to the aberrations now known as mutations.A gene, by definition, is a living particle that reproduces itself, and nearly always it does so exactly. But occasionally it forms an imperfect copy of itself. If this altered gene is able to reproduce itself in its new form. The result is a mutation...a permanent change in some trait of the organism.The mutation process, in short, supplies the building blocks of evolution. With this discovery, the biologists of the 20th century started to unravel the mechanisms of that evolutionary process which Charles Darwin and their successors of the 19th century had suggested but only dimly understood. [G]enetics will surely play a major role in the still infant technology of biological engineering. Already it has borne a huge harvest of “practical” results through improvements in breeds of food plants and animals. And genetics steadily becomes more and more important as a tool for improvements in the prevention, diagnosis and treatment of many diseases.There remains the ultimate hope that genetics will point the way to improving the human species. Some of the early attempts to apply eugenics in the human realm were based more on enthusiasm than on understanding. But as our understanding of the genetics of human populations grows, the possibilities for useful application of our knowledge doubtless will multiply.”Who was Theo Dobzhansky? He was a major leader in investigating the relationship between genetics and the study of evolution. Born in Russia, he came to the California Institute of Technology in 1929 and in 1940 became a professor of zoology at Columbia University. In 1937, he published a very important book, Genetics and the Origin of Species. In this book, he made a strong case for uniting genetics with evolutionary biology.Source: BHP created this text from Dobzhansky, Theodosius. 1950. “Genetics.” Scientific American 183: 55-58.Dobzhansky
STUDENT MATERIALSSTUDENT MATERIALSS-10BIG HISTORY PROJECT / ASSESSMENTINVESTIGATION—EVOLVING THEORIESText 6: BHP Chart on the Age of the Earth 2017This chart shows major changes in the ways people have measured the age of the Earth.DateNameMethod Used to Calculate the Age of the EarthAge of the Earth1650James UssherAnalyzed Biblical references and generations referenced in Bible.Earth created on October 22, 4004, BCE. Earth is around 6,020 years old.1788James HuttonObserved and measured erosion and sedimentation in present day, and used present to hypothesize about Earth’s history. Hutton claimed his studies could “find no vestige of a beginning—no prospect of an end.”Earth is much older than 6,000 years, since there is no evidence of a beginning or end.1830Charles LyellLike Hutton, observed current process to explain Earth’s past. Agreed with Hutton that Earth’s history was over an “inconceivably vast” period of time.Estimated about 80 million years for the Cenozoic Era alone or about 300 million years old.1862Lord KelvinKelvin assumed that the Earth initially was totally molten and calculated a date based on cooling through conduction and radiation. He used laws of physics and thermodynamics and heat measurements to develop a mathematical approach.Earth was anywhere between 20 million and 40 million years old.1899John JollyTo determine the age of the oceans, Jolly calculated the rate at which they would have accumulated sodium.Oceans, and hence the Earth, is between 80 million and 100 million years old.1927Ernest Rutherford & Arthur HolmesNew discoveries of radioactivity by Rutherford and Curie showed that radioactive decay is constant. By measuring the decay in minerals, particularly uranium and lead, scientists began to estimate the age of rocks.Earth is between 1.6 and 3 billion years old.1953Clair PattersonAssumed meteorites are left over from the formation of the Solar System; used a new tool, mass spectrometer, to measure isotopes in meteorites. Oldest rock is about 4.5 billion years old.Earth is 4.550 billion years old (give or take 70 million years).Source: BHP created this text from Matterson, James. “Historical Development of Dating Methods,” in Jack Rink and Jaren Thompson (eds.), Encyclopedia of Scientific Dating Methods, 2015: 319-329.
STUDENT MATERIALSSTUDENT MATERIALSS-11BIG HISTORY PROJECT / ASSESSMENTINVESTIGATION—EVOLVING THEORIESText 7: Crick’s Letter to His SonWhat is this letter? “On March 19th of 1953, weeks before it was announced to the public [in a letter to the magazine Nature], scientist Francis Crick excitedly wrote a letter to his son [Michael] and told him of one of the most important scientific developments of modern times: his co-discovery of the ‘beautiful’ structure of DNA, the molecule responsible for carrying the genetic instructions of living organisms; or, as Crick explained it to 12-year-old Michael, ‘the basic copying mechanism by which life comes from life.’ Although DNA was isolated back in the 1860s by Friedrich Miescher, its now-famous double-helix structure wasn’t correctly modelled until the early 1950s by Crick and his colleague, James Watson, thanks in no small part to work already done by Maurice Wilkins, Rosalind Franklin, and Raymond Gosling. In 1962, Crick, Watson, and Wilkins were awarded the Nobel Prize for their efforts.” Source: The Letters of Note https://goo.gl/IL3msV19 Portugal PlaceCambridge19 March ‘53My Dear MichaelJim Watson and I have probably made a most important discovery. We have built a model for the structure of de-oxi-ribose-nucleic-acid (read it carefully) called D.N.A. for short. You may remember that the genes of the chromosomes - which carry the hereditary factors - are made up of protein and D.N.A.Our structure is very beautiful. D.N.A. can be thought of roughly as a very long chain with flat bits sticking out. The flat bits are called the “bases”. The formula is rather like this.
STUDENT MATERIALSSTUDENT MATERIALSS-12BIG HISTORY PROJECT / ASSESSMENTINVESTIGATION—EVOLVING THEORIES| sugar —— base| Phosphorus| sugar —— base| Phosphorus| sugar —— base| Phosphorus: and so on.Now we have two of these chains winding round each other - each one is a helix - and the chain, made up sugar and phosphorus, is on the outside, and the bases are all on the inside. I can’t draw it very well, but it looks like this.The model looks much nicer than this.Now the exciting thing is that while there are 4 different bases, we find we can only put certain pairs of them together. The bases have names. They are Adenine, Guanine, Thymine & Cytosine. I will call them A, G, T and C. Now we find that the pairs we can make - which have one base from one chain joined to one base from another - are only A with T and G with C.
STUDENT MATERIALSSTUDENT MATERIALSS-13BIG HISTORY PROJECT / ASSESSMENTINVESTIGATION—EVOLVING THEORIESNow on one chain, as far as we can see, one can have the bases in any order, but if their order is fixed, then the order on the other chain is also fixed. For example, suppose the first chain goes, then the second must go A TT AC GA TG CT AT AIt is like a code. If you are given one set of letters you can write down the orders.Now we believe that the D.N.A. is a code. That is, the order of the bases (the letters) makes one gene different from another gene (just as one page of print is different from another). You can now see how Nature makes copies of the genes. Because if the two chains unwind into two separate chains, and if each chain then makes another chain come together on it, then because A always goes with T, and G with C, we shall get two copies where we had one before.
STUDENT MATERIALSSTUDENT MATERIALSS-14BIG HISTORY PROJECT / ASSESSMENTINVESTIGATION—EVOLVING THEORIESFor exampleIn others words we think we have found the basic copying mechanism by which life comes from life. The beauty of our model is that the shape of it is such that only these pairs can go together, though they could pair up in other ways if they were floating about freely. You can understand that we are very excited. We have to have a letter off to Nature in a day or so.Read this carefully so that you understand it. When you come home we will show you the model.Lots of love,DaddyA — TT — AC — GA — TG — CT — AT — AChains separateA TT AC GA TG CT AT Anew chains formA — T T — AT — A A — TC — G G — CA — T T — AG — C C — GT — A A — TT — A A — T
STUDENT MATERIALSSTUDENT MATERIALSS-15BIG HISTORY PROJECT / ASSESSMENTINVESTIGATION—EVOLVING THEORIESText 8: The Episodic Nature of Evolutionary Change“On November 23, 1859, the day before his revolutionary book hit the stands, Charles Darwin received an extraordinary letter from his friend Thomas Henry Huxley. It offered warm support in the coming conflict. But it also contained a warning: You have loaded yourself with the unnecessary difficulty in adopting Natura non facit saltum [Nature does not make leaps] so unreservedly.Darwin was a strict adherent to this ancient motto. As a discipline of Charles Lyell, the apostle of gradualism in geology, Darwin portrayed evolution as a stately and orderly process, working at a speed so slow that no person could hope to observe it in a lifetime. Huxley felt that Darwin was digging a ditch for his own theory. Natural selection required no postulate about rates; it could operate just as well if evolution proceeded at a rapid pace. The road ahead was rocky enough; why harness the theory of natural selection to an assumption both unnecessary and probably false? The fossil record offered no support for gradual change: whole faunas had been wiped out during disarmingly short intervals. New species almost always appeared suddenly in the fossil record with no immediate links to ancestors in older rocks in the same region. I do not know why Darwin chose to follow Lyell and the gradualists so strictly. But I am certain of one thing, preference for one view or the other had nothing to do with superior information. On this question, nature spoke and continues to speak in multifarious and muffled voices. The geologic record seemed to provide as much evidence for cataclysmic as for gradual change. Therefore, in defending gradualism as a nearly universal tempo, Darwin had to reject literal appearance and common sense. Darwin’s argument still persists. I wish only to point out that it was never ‘seen’ in the rocks.I believe that Huxley was right in his warning. The modern theory of evolution does not require gradual change. The operation of Darwinism processes should yield exactly what we see in the fossil record. It is gradualism we must reject, not Darwinism. The history of most fossil species includes two features inconsistent with gradualism. 1. Stasis: Most species exhibit no directional change. They appear in the fossil record looking much the same was when they disappear. 2. Sudden appearance: In any local area, a species does not arise gradually by steady transformation of its ancestors; it appears at once and fully formed.I prefer this scheme as the model of punctuated equilibria. Gradualism sometimes works well. (I often fly over the folded Appalachians and marvel at the striking parallel ridges left standing by gradual erosion of the softer rocks surrounding them.) I make a simple plea for pluralism.”Who was Stephen Jay Gould? Stephen Jay Gould (1941–2002) was an evolutionary biologist, paleontologist, and a historian of science who taught at Harvard University for over thirty years. Gould warned against scientists allowing their beliefs or an authority to intrude on their interpretations. This sometimes led to ignoring evidence. Gould argued, for example, that Darwin was so committed to his belief in “gradualism” as described by Charles Lyell that he ignored the evidence in the fossil record. Gould, by the way, did not reject gradual change though in studying the fossil record, he and his colleague Niles Eldridge argued the evidence also supports sudden change.Source: BHP edited this text from the original essay: Gould, Stephen Jay. “Evolution’s Erratic Pace.” Natural History 86, no. 5 (1977): 12-16.
STUDENT MATERIALSSTUDENT MATERIALSS-16BIG HISTORY PROJECT / ASSESSMENTINVESTIGATION—EVOLVING THEORIESText 9: Drug Resistance ExplainedWho is Marlene Zuk? Dr. Marlene Zuk is an evolutionary biologist. She is professor of biology at the University of Minnesota. Growing up, Dr. Zuk became interested in insects, and decided to study biology. She earned a Ph.D. in biology at the University of Michigan and has become an expert in germs and bug reproduction, among other specialties. Dr. Zuk has written four books and over 100 articles in peer-reviewed journals. You could learn more about Dr. Zuk and her research at https://cbs.umn.edu/zuk-lab/home.Drug Resistance“People can be forgiven for wondering what difference it makes how we kill microorganisms. After all, soap or bleach kills bacteria, and so does penicillin. So why does it matter exactly how you kill them? It does matter, and the reason for the consequences of killing bacteria with penicillin or killing them with Ivory soap has to do with evolution. Furthermore, I suspect that part of the confusion in the mind of the public lies in the use of euphemisms like “develop” and “change through time,” rather than what we really mean, which is evolve. Bacteria don’t “develop” resistance, as if it were a muscle nurtured by going to a microbial gym. Instead, they had it all along, or more accurately a small proportion of them did. The process of natural selection, the same one that brought us a four-chambered heart and different sizes of beaks on Galapagos finches, does the rest. Antibiotics mainly kill bacteria by targeting components in the cell wall, a structure that surrounds bacteria but which our own cells lack. Antibiotics are highly selective—unlike soap and water, which get rid of bacteria indiscriminately, through mechanical means. When you take an antibiotic, a few of the bacterial cells in your body already happen to have genes that enable them to be resistant to it, just by random chance. You have many millions of bacteria, so it’s not too surprising that they vary. If you don’t take the whole course of antibiotics, say the 5 or 7 or 14 days your doctor recommends—or sometimes even if you do—enough of the resistant bacteria may remain to establish a new infection.And they multiply incredibly quickly, leaving their equally resistant progeny in much greater numbers. The resistant bacteria will spread the way bacteria do, but now they will outnumber the vulnerable ones in the population. Then, when the same antibiotic is used again, it can’t gain a toehold because a far greater proportion of the newly-produced bacteria are unaffected by its use. The bacteria have evolved. In contrast, although soap and water don’t completely annihilate the bacteria either, they aren’t selective. The bacteria that remain are similar to the ones that went swirling down the drain, and so their offspring are equally vulnerable to the next scrubbing. So using soap or bleach-based cleansers is good, but inappropriate application of antibiotics will be worse than ineffective because it drives evolution.
STUDENT MATERIALSSTUDENT MATERIALSS-17BIG HISTORY PROJECT / ASSESSMENTINVESTIGATION—EVOLVING THEORIESAs microbiologists Dan Andersson and Bruce Levin bluntly stated in the scientific journal “Current Opinion in Microbiology” almost 10 years ago: “The use of antibiotics by humans can be seen as an evolutionary experiment of enormous magnitude.” We’re seeing the results of that experiment now. Economic costs of drug resistance—longer hospital stays, use of more expensive alternative medications and higher death rates—have been estimated at anywhere from $150 million to $30 billion each year, depending on exactly how you crunch the numbers.What do we do? For starters, we all have to understand the crucial role that evolution plays in our lives. Doctors need Darwin, and the media has to stop using vague terminology that makes it sound as if bacteria were suddenly, inexplicably motivated to deter penicillin through spite.Scientists are also experimenting with altering essential proteins in hosts that bacteria use to mount infections. Right now they’re using mice that have genetic mutations that make the proteins inaccessible to the bacteria. It’s not clear exactly how this would be applied to people, but these treatments wouldn’t use conventional antibiotics and hence might be less subject to evolving resistance. Early days, but hopeful.”Source: BHP edited this text from the original essay: Zuk, Marlene. “Drug Resistance, Explained.” The New York Times, March 27, 2008. https://archive.nytimes.com/well.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/03/27/drug-resistance-explained/
STUDENT MATERIALSSTUDENT MATERIALSS-18BIG HISTORY PROJECT / ASSESSMENTINVESTIGATION—EVOLVING THEORIESAnalysis of texts in this InvestigationText NameLexile Measure1Common Core Stretch Grade Band22Mean Sentence LengthFlesch Ease3Evidence For and Problems with Darwin’s Theory900L4-512.9651.9Charles Lyell, Principles of Geology1150L6-818.2758.3Darwinism Fifty Years After: The Biological Lesson of Evolution1270L9-1020.1245.5The 1933 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine Awarded to Thomas H. Morgan980L6-813.5637.2Genetics1090L6-816.4840.5BHP Chart on Age of the Earth, 20171210L9-1017.638.8Crick’s Letter to His Son, 19531020L6-817.0781.4The Episodic Nature of Evolutionary Change980L6-813.2649.9Drug Resistance Explained1200L9-101740.11 Lexile measure indicates the reading demand of the text in terms of its semantic difficulty and syntactic complexity. The Lexile scale generally ranges from 200L to 1700L. The Common Core emphasizes the role of text complexity in evaluating student readiness for college and careers.2 We are using the Common Core “stretch” grade bands. The Common Core Standards advocate a “staircase” of increasing text complexity so that students “stretch” to read a certain proportion of texts from the next higher text complexity band.3 In the Flesch Reading Ease test, higher scores indicate that the material is relatively easy to read while lower scores indicate greater difficulty. Scores in the 50–70 range should be easily understood by 13- to 15-year-olds, while those in the 0–30 range are appropriate for university graduates.